A quiet bluestone terrace with teak chairs, evergreen hedges and late-autumn planting behind an established brick-and-taupe townhome.

Renting at Westport Crossing or Buying a Pittsford Townhome

For about 18 years, the parcel at 75 Monroe Avenue was known simply as 75 Monroe. Today it is Westport Crossing, a canal-side apartment community in the Village of Pittsford. Tenants began moving in during the first week of October. Within days, developer Chris DiMarzo of Mark IV Enterprises told RochesterFirst that 75 percent of the one-, two- and three-bedroom units were already spoken for.

Speed of leasing is only part of the story. The new housing coming to Pittsford, the kind with no roof to replace and no driveway to plow, is arriving as rentals. A household that wants less house and wants to stay in this town has two choices. It can rent something new by the month, or it can buy something already standing. Westport Crossing's pricing shows how much that difference is worth to the people signing leases.

The Price of a Key at 75 Monroe Avenue

Westport Crossing's floor-plan page lists these starting rents as of mid-November 2026: $2,375 a month for a one-bedroom, one-bath unit of 734 to 743 square feet; $2,895 for a two-bedroom, two-bath unit of 975 to 1,271 square feet; and $3,660 for a 1,348-square-foot three-bedroom with two baths. Per square foot, the smallest unit is the most expensive. The one-bedroom comes to about $3.20 a month for each square foot, the entry two-bedroom about $2.97, and the three-bedroom about $2.72. That is how rent works when the address is the main thing being sold.

The address is the point. "The key is you're in the center of the village," DiMarzo told RochesterFirst, describing residents who can walk to restaurants, bars and stores, and adding that "there's really not a lot of options to rent in this area." The 75 percent figure he gave the station is the clearest sign of demand for that combination of walkability and no upkeep.

More units are coming. In August 2026, the County of Monroe Industrial Development Agency approved $9 million in incentives for the next phases. Rochester Business Journal reported that the $45.2 million project includes 100 all-electric apartments, a restaurant and a boathouse. The agency's August 18 board minutes put the phase-two rent range at $1,900 to $4,000, and work on the restaurant and more housing was still going on in early October.

The Same Money, Measured Against a Mortgage

Compare the entry rent with the ownership math published in early October. In his October 7 Rochester Realty Review column for Rochester Business Journal, Siwiec put the Monroe County median home at $305,000. He calculated that principal and interest on that house had risen from $1,829 a month at February's 6 percent mortgage rate to $2,147 at the 7.57 percent rate on the day he wrote. Rates have eased a little since then. Freddie Mac's survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 7.11 percent for the week of November 12, 2026, compared with 6.24 percent a year earlier.

Against that October snapshot, Westport Crossing's smallest unit rents for about $228 a month more than principal and interest on a median-priced house in the county, and November's slightly lower rate widens the gap a little. A mortgage payment leaves out property taxes, insurance and repairs, which an owner pays on top. Pittsford prices also run above the county median. In its Winter 2025–2026 newsletter, the Town says Pittsford's housing costs at every price level generally sit above most other communities because people keep moving in.

The comparison does show what a Westport Crossing lease is buying. Renters there pay a mortgage-sized amount each month for a village location, a new building and no long-term financing commitment at a 7 percent rate. The appetite for that trade suggests many households in Pittsford value flexibility and walkability right now and are willing to pay for them. For a household moving here from out of state, it also gives them a place to learn the town before they choose a street. Whether village taxes apply to a property is a separate question for anyone weighing a purchase near Main Street, and it is covered in our look at the village line in Pittsford pricing.

What Is for Sale Is Already Built

Buyers who want ownership with the same freedom from upkeep turn to Pittsford's established associations. That supply is fixed and familiar. Wood Creek, on Wood Creek Drive, is a privately owned community of 126 townhouses. Its 2019 homeowners handbook says the association maintains building exteriors and grounds, and that dues pay for landscaping, snowplowing, trash collection, association insurance, water and reserves. The current dues amount sits with the association, and the handbook's description of coverage is from 2019.

The Tobey communities follow a similar model at different scales. Tobey Court has 93 townhomes with quarterly dues and set schedules for trash and recycling, mowing and snow clearing. Tobey Woods is a 32-unit condominium community with quarterly assessments, and Tobey Meadows has 30 single-family homes under a homeowners association that handles landscaping, trash and snow removal.

Seen alongside Westport Crossing, these communities are an older version of the same promise. The association handles the exterior, the grounds and the snow, and the owner keeps the deed and the job of resale. With Pittsford's newest named projects arriving as rentals, a buyer in this segment is choosing among a set number of existing units, and how well a particular unit has been kept up matters more than it would in a market with new inventory.

Clover Street and the Next Round

The project furthest along in the pipeline is also a rental. Pittsford Oaks, from Daniele Management & Development, is planned for the former Barn Bazaar and Five Star Bank site at the corner of Jefferson Road and Clover Street in Tobey Village Office Park. Rochester Business Journal reported the September 2025 Planning Board approval: 171 apartments, with 121 one-bedrooms, 40 two-bedrooms and 10 three-bedrooms. The Pittsford Oaks site advertises a grand opening in fall 2027 and apartments starting at $1,899. At the time of approval, RochesterFirst reported that the developer expected average rents above $3,000. Elsewhere in town, Dunnwood Green on Dunnwood Green Lane is a rental community with one- to three-bedroom homes listed between $1,900 and $4,200 a month.

Demand for smaller homes to own is on the Town's radar too. In the Winter 2025–2026 Pittsford Messenger, the Town writes that many residents want to downsize while remaining in Pittsford, and that single-family attached houses are popular with owners who are downsizing. The projects with names, addresses and opening dates in this post are rentals, so this winter's buyer of an attached home is choosing among the ones already built.

The County Market Behind Both Choices

For a Pittsford owner thinking about leaving a larger house, the sale side matters as much as the next address. Siwiec's October column described Monroe County as split over the previous 12 months. Closings fell 18 percent and expired listings rose 16 percent, yet the median sale price rose 11 percent and 83 percent of homes that sold closed above list price. His conclusion was that homes priced correctly, kept in good condition and well staged still have a good chance of selling over asking.

Supply is loosening a little but remains thin. The New York State Association of Realtors' third-quarter 2026 report put the Monroe County median at $312,000, up 11 percent from a year earlier, with 709 homes for sale, up 21.6 percent, and 1.2 months of supply. Rochester Business Journal noted that September's 1.2 months of supply was the county's highest since 2020, though still far below the 6.0 to 6.5 months considered balanced.

For an owner leaving a larger house, the new rentals make a three-step sequence possible. The owner can sell into a county market that still pays for a well-prepared home, rent new in the village or near Clover Street, and buy a smaller home once the right unit in an established association comes up, without having to time all three moves together. The price of that flexibility is a mortgage-sized rent paid for a stretch of time, and Westport Crossing's leasing pace shows how many people are already paying it.

The rents and payments here are figures published on the dates noted. This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm your own numbers with a qualified professional.

If you are deciding between a lease at 75 Monroe Avenue and a deed in one of Pittsford's established townhome communities, or working out what your current home would bring before you choose, a conversation with Renee DeMars can start with a home valuation and a clear look at the timing. Let's Connect.

Your Trusted Agent, Ready to Help

With a deep understanding of the market and a commitment to your goals, every step of your property journey is handled with care and precision. Whether buying or selling, expect clear guidance, honest advice, and a smooth, stress-free experience tailored just for you.

Follow Me on Instagram